March 1877- William S. Bell, Founder

Fall 1877 – September 1878 Lewis Bridgman

September 1878 – August 1879 William S. Bell

August 1879 – May 1880 Church closed

May 1880 – 1884 William S. Bell

1884 – 1885 (Exact dates unknown) - J.A.B. Ogilvie

1884 – 1885 (Exact dates unknown) - C. Rowland Hill

May 1885 - William S. Bell

(Exact dates unknown) - Renion Norton

1889 (Exact dates unknown) - F.R.G. Wilcox

November 1890 – September 1895 - W.S. Washburn

September 1895 – December 1898 - W.J. Marsh

January 1899 – May 1899 - H.W. Jenney

May 1899 – September 1901 - Elias Fenn Lyman

November 1901 – June 1905 - J.S. Spittell

June 1905 – March 1907 - William J. Watt

April 1907 – September 1909 - Virgil B. Hill

April 1910 – March 1912 - Jas. Smeal Macinnes

April 1912 – June 1913 - John T. Steele

July 1913 – May 1919 - George E. Green

July 1919 – July 1919 — Eldridge

August 1919 – November 1920 - Robert N. Chord

May 1921 – June 1924 - Wilfred Wakefield

June 1924 – November 1926 - Henry A. Dairymple

November 1926 – March 1929 - Albert R. Hyatt

April 1929 – June 1937 - Joseph Sharp, Ph.D.

November 1937 – March 1944 - George W. Reinmuth

September 1944 – November 1946 - Wallace W. Russell

December 1946 – July 1947 - George J. Eisenach

September 1947 – February 1952 - James A. Sanaker

February 1952 – March 1952 - George J. Eisenach

April 1952 – December 1953 - Robert W. Shields

June 1954 – September 1957 - Hugh Gackie

October 1957 – June 1958 - Roger Grow

July 1958 – August 1960 - Paul Miguel

November 1960 – August 1962 - Richard Seaman

September 1962 – January 1963 - Jerry Ferguson

January 1963 – March 1968 - Donald R. Asman

September 1968 – August 1969 - Cornelius Wilkens

August 1969 - 1977 - Milo Sheldon

July 1978 – May 1983 - Roger Kube

September 1983 – 1991 - Ron Nuss-Warren

July 1991 – September 1991 - Supply Pastors

1991 - 1995 - Jeanne Johnston

1995 - 1996 - Sue Burris, Interim

October 1996 – May 2001 - Susan Taylor

June 2001 - August 2003 – Elaine Miller, Interim

September 2003 - March 2005 - Tom Zulke